How to Identify Real Leather Shoes

How to Identify Real Leather Shoes

Real leather products are beautiful and are great investment pieces. In the footwear world, a genuine leather shoe adapts to your foot over time, so the shoe will fit and feel better with more wear. This makes it more comfortable and also gives it unique characteristics. How great is that?!

But how can you guarantee that an item is made of genuine leather and not artificial? There are a few characteristics to look out for and some simple tests that will help guide you to be more assured that you are not being fooled. These may be applied to any type of product in question such shoes, bags or clothing.

A few tips and tests to guide you on how to identify real leather:

    1. Read the Label
      Simple enough, the simplest way to know what a product is made from is by checking the tag or label - manufacturers definitely want to share the information if products are made of real leather. If it is not on the actual product, it may be on an information card or leaflet that comes in the packaging of the item (just like with Rana Cheikha shoes!). 
      Real Leather Shoes Care and Maintenance Card
    2. Notice the Weight
      Leather shoes tend to be heavier in weight than synthetic shoes. The type of shoe makes a difference of course, so if you might be in a situation comparing two shoes, make sure they are the same type (a sandal versus a sandal, a boot versus a boot, etc.).

    3. Smell It

      Natural leather products have a beautiful and unique ‘leather’ smell that cannot be mimicked on synthetic materials. Products such as leather smelling sprays do exist, but these tend to wear out over time. Boutiques that sell leather items usually have that beautiful and distinct smoky smell that you can sense right upon enteringHow To Identify Real Leather Shoes Smell Leather

    4. Feel It
      Genuine leather is a beautiful and versatile material. There are many different types of leathers that differ in property, but a common characteristic of real leather is that it is smooth and supple to touch - almost silky. Artificial leather is either much stiffer or more elastic in comparison.
      How To Identify Real Leather Shoes Smooth Touch
    5. Closely Examine the Leather
      A. Natural Marks

      Scratches, creases and wrinkles are a quality that you usually want to avoid when purchasing a new product, but natural leathers tend to have distinguishable marks and imperfections on them. This is because leather comes from real animals of course, and scratches, stretch marks and veining are a few of the characteristics that you will expect to see on their skins. In saying that, marks will become less visible if a skin is treated (such as with dyes or coatings). A heavily treated natural leather is still real leather, although it will lose some of the natural qualities that may have been on the hide. The quality of life of the animal affects the amount of scarring to expect on the skin, and this is when leather grading comes into play. Leather grades A, B and C are used as an indicator to identify the amount of damage or defect on a skin (this is separate from the actual quality).
      B. Color Change
      The color of natural leathers will change over time and when exposed to light or when folded, while synthetic materials will remain more rigid and even.
      C. Porousness
      The pores in natural leathers are distributed unevenly and have inconsistent patterns. Synthetic leathers, although may have pores (as manufacturers have found more ways to make them look more like real leather), will have a consistent repeating pattern. These pores, actually stamped onto the material, may look realistic but in fact are not.
      How To Identify Real Leather Shoes Natural Marks

    6. The Scratch Test
      If scratched gently, fine particles are removed from the surface of a natural leather product, while artificial leather will usually stay intact. If you want to use this technique to test a product, make sure you do so from an area that is hidden and that won’t be visible. If the scratch does end up being visible, you can always use one of our tips from the How To Fix Scratched Leather Shoes blog!

    7. The Fire Test
      A small fire test is a quick way to identity natural from artificial leather. If the leather loses shape when heated, it is not genuine leather as real leather will not deform under fire. It will also smell like burnt hair, versus the burning plastic smell of artificial leather (do this if there is a small unnoticeable area you can test on).
      How To Identify Real Leather Shoes Fire Test
    8. The Price Point
      There is no doubt that real leather products will always be more expensive than synthetic ones - not only because of all the great qualities, but also because of the care and expertise needed when working with real leather. Genuine leather shoes are also a lot better for your feet, more comfortable and will definitely last a lot longer too!

Real leather products are unique in character and behavior.  The more you can touch and feel the product, the easier it is to identify a product as being made of real versus artificial leather. At the end of it, if a product feels like plastic, it most likely is made of synthetic materials. But if it is smooth, feels and looks luxurious, it probably is the genuine leather product that deserves your attention.

How To Identify Real Leather Shoes Supple soft shoes

So shop the Rana Cheikha and Wander Collections to invest in a pair of handmade shoes in genuine leather. 

Also use our guides that include How To Keep your Shoes Shinning and Travel the World with Your Best Shoes to make sure they’re always looking great!

Signing-off: The Shoe Advisor 


// Get in touch here or by email at for more insight, queries and information //

Connect with us on Instagram & Facebook

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Also in The Shoe Advisor

Why we Love Shoes Shoe Obsession
Shoes... Why DO We Love Them So Much?

Well, in a nutshell, shoes are an incredible product. They have history and function, they are a product of design with a need of technical know-how in construction and form. They art an art and a nod to objects of artisanal creation. Stereotypes may place women as being obsessive over shoes, but in reality, this obsession is just as present in men as it is in women. It has become quite obvious that men too can be just as passionate and enthusiastic about them.

Continue Reading

Taking Care of the Heel Covers of Your Shoes
Taking Care of Your Shoe Heel Covers

We might like to try a funky pair of a very fashionable and ‘IN’ style shoes, but the truth is, you’ll probably wear them a few times and feel that they are no longer relevant in your closet. In my opinion, a good shoe purchase is a smart purchase, and investing in a great pair of classic shoes means that that the style will always be relevant. Just check out the tips in 10 Tips for Finding the Right Shoe or How to Choose the Right Shoes that are Comfortable and Elegant.

Continue Reading

What Shoes to Wear Perfect Styling
What Shoes to Wear: The Do’s and Don’ts

You don’t need to have a plethora of clothes in your closet to feel like you have enough to create a wide range of outfits. A good selection of staple pieces can give you enough styling versatility and remain relevant over time. Shoes are a great accessory that you can use alongside a few classic clothing options to take you through the seasons in a stylish breeze. Although I would usually advocate to wear what you want to and feel good in at all times, there are a few Do’s and Don’ts that are quite helpful to consider while picking out shoes for your outfits. These can help make decisions faster and, to some extent, less painful too!

Continue Reading